manual
Natasha Laging22 Sept 2016
NEWS

Manual no longer automatic

It’s an increasing trend for drivers to get their licences without ever learning to use a manual transmission

Research figures from VicRoads show that many new and young drivers are choosing automatic licenses over the traditional manual. And in the last decade, the Aussie car industry has seen a steady shift towards auto transmission.

Indeed, sales of manual cars are declining so fast, some experts believe the ‘stick shift’ transmission and three pedals will eventually become niche, play things catering for wealthy sports car lovers.

Is it because automatic transmission technology has dramatically improved? Or are we just getting lazy?

As we discussed last year, automatics have the potential (according to the specific needs of the purchaser and his or her buying decision) to provide higher performance, better economy and even improved control in high-pressure motorsport environments.

We asked our Facebook audience what’s wrong with manuals. A few selected comments feature below:

carsales.com.au Facebook:

Tony Robinson
It’s easy… that’s the way of the world now… it has to be easy…shame really. No one really knows how to actually drive anymore. Just ask anyone if they know how to heel and toe?

Kalid David Al-Musawi
With the growing number of road congestion I believe that has an impact because who wants to drive a manual on stop start for hours, gets very annoying. Autos have come a long way and far more comfortable to drive and performance is a lot better.

Jamaine Lee Prieditis Parry
I'm a part of this younger generation; the main issue was not having access to a manual vehicle to learn in. I bought my first car on my learners which was automatic, so I lost the motivation to learn how to drive manual, and just got my automatic license. Once I got onto my P plates, I actually needed a manual licence for work purposes. So I learned how to drive manual in 2 days and had the driving test on the third day, and passed quite easily in a massive 4WD.

Jaime Chen
It's an Aussie thing I guess, people are getting lazy here and purely rely on auto. Have a look at the cars in UK and other countries in Europe, manual are still very popular. Even Americans drive more manual than we do

Jonathan William Whittacker
Manuals are fun to drive, but as a daily driver it doesn't make much sense, autos are much easier to drive in stop-start traffic

Liam Clarke
People too lazy to actually learn how to drive a car. Should be no such thing as an auto only licence.

Des Lindsay
Without the stick you only learn how to steer a car not drive....

motoring.com.au facebook:

Andrew McCluskey
With the increase of speed traps etc.. Australia is becoming a nanny state. Less kids are becoming real car enthusiasts and more are just interested in cars solely as a mode of transport which carries more freedoms then public transport. People still like cars but are more enthused about the styling, the spec sheet and equipment.

Also back in the day, manuals where much better propositions, they would be 4 speed compared to 3 speed; 6 speed compared to 4 speed meaning not only where they faster but more fuel efficient too also auto options where usually more expensive making the decision much easier.

Today, automatics usually have more gears then manuals and can shift quicker too meaning in some cases there objectively faster and more efficient too. Also an increasing amount of cars come as auto only and in addition, those young people who are car enthusiasts may have a hard time finding the car they want on the used car market in manual just because most people ticked the auto box when new

Thomas Lodge
There's absolutely nothing wrong with manual gearboxes. It's my first choice of gearbox, every time. Despite manual gearboxes being the obvious choice for outright driving involvement, automatics (whether torque converter or GOOD dual clutch varieties) are either as efficient, or nearly as efficient.

Some dual clutch gearboxes are a bit quicker than a well driven manual. But, despite paddle shifting available on the automatic variations, and automatically blipping the throttle on downshifting, NO auto can match the fun of heel and toe downshifting in a manual car, and a crash box manual truck

Brad Warren
Cats. Bunch of cats you auto drivers. I'll never own an auto until I'm too old to push the clutch in cos my legs have seized up !!

Bob Cilia
If you can't control a vehicle you shouldn't get a license. Auto license should only be an option for special circumstances.

Have your say below…

Share this article
Written byNatasha Laging
See all articles
Our team of independent expert car reviewers and journalistsMeet the team
Stay up to dateBecome a carsales member and get the latest news, reviews and advice straight to your inbox.
Disclaimer
Please see our Editorial Guidelines & Code of Ethics (including for more information about sponsored content and paid events). The information published on this website is of a general nature only and doesn’t consider your particular circumstances or needs.

If the price does not contain the notation that it is "Drive Away", the price may not include additional costs, such as stamp duty and other government charges.
Download the carsales app
    AppStoreDownloadGooglePlayDownload
    App Store and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc. Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google LLC.
    © CAR Group Ltd 1999-2024
    In the spirit of reconciliation we acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of Country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.